Indentured Servitude

Indentured servitude functioned as an alternative to slavery in Westerville.

Samuel McDannald’s family moved to the Central College area from Bath County, Virginia in 1813. By 1817, he had inherited two enslaved half-brothers named Jack and Benjamin Lee from an aunt in Virginia, Elizabeth McDannald Sitlington. Sitlington provided Benjamin and Jack with $15 each and gave them a pass that permitted them to travel through Virginia. Her will also instructed that McDannald was to free Benjamin and Jack when they turned 25.  However, a judge told McDannald that under Ohio’s constitution, he could not legally keep the two teenagers as slaves.[1]

Instead, McDannald indentured them for roughly four more years, until their 21st birthdays - the maximum amount of time he could legally control their labor under Ohio law. Although no longer enslaved, Benjamin and Jack were not technically free either. McDannald was to provide food, clothes, shelter, and reading and writing lessons but would not pay them for their work. The teenagers did not sign or mark the indenture themselves, perhaps implying that this arrangement was made without their consent. Even if they were given a choice, it is impossible to know whether they agreed of their own volition or whether they gave their answer under duress.[2]

Definitions

When an individual signs a voluntary contract to work for someone for a certain number of years (usually seven) without pay as a way to pay off debts, in return for free passage to the North American colonies from Europe, or to learn a trade.

Indenture Papers, 11/22/1817, M26005, Westerville History Museum.

References

[1] Will of Elizabeth McDannald Sitlington and Inventory of Elizabeth McDannald Sitlington as they appears in Jean Randolph Bruns, Abstract of Wills and Inventories of Bath County, 1791-1842 (Baltimore: Genealogical Publishing Co., 1995), 84-86; Public Opinion, 8/20/1891.

[2] Indenture Papers (M26005), File on McDannald Family, 11/22/1817, Westerville History Museum.

How to Cite This Source

Please cite this toolkit (Chicago Manual of Style) as 'Westerville History Museum, "Racism in Westerville History," Westerville Public Library, last modified January 23, 2023, https://westervillelibrary.org/racism-history.

Need a citation in a different style (such as MLA or APA)? Try this citation generator.

Jump to:

Westerville History MuseumWesterville History Museum

Through historical collections and learning experiences, deepen your understanding of your community and its place in the world. From Underground Railroad activities to anti-alcohol efforts, the people who came before you have shaped the course of American history and given Westerville a unique legacy.
Through historical collections and learning experiences, deepen your understanding of your community and its place in the world. From Underground Railroad activities to anti-alcohol efforts, the people who came before you have shaped the course of American history and given Westerville a unique legacy.
Back to Top